Etienne KLEIN

photo_etienne_klein.jpg
  • STATUS and ADDRESS

Researcher (DR), Dept. Forest, Grassland and Freshwater Ecology (EFPA).
Also associated to the unit Ecology of Mediterranean Forests.

 

INRA - Unité de Biostatistiques et Processus Spatiaux (UR546)
Domaine St-Paul - Site Agroparc
84914 Avignon Cedex

Tél.: + 33 4 32 72 21 54
Fax: +33 4 32 72 21 82

 

  • POSITIONS AND EDUCATION

INRA Researcher since 2003
Assistant professor in statistics, department OMIP, Institut National Agronomique Paris-Grignon (1999-2003)
PhD Student, department Ecology, Systematics & Evolution, University Paris-Sud Orsay. 1996-1999

 

  • RESEARCH INTERESTS

Within population biology, my research interests concern dispersal of plant propagules (pollen and seeds). Estimating dispersal kernels in various experimental designs, understanding the impacts of long distance dispersal and forecasting gene flow in mosaic landscapes are my main activities. During my PhD, I worked on transgene escape in agro-ecosystems. I am still engaged on this topic through collaborations, but I have mostly worked on gene flow in forest species since my arrival in dept EFPA. I am currently focusing on the estimation of dispersal kernels and components of male/female fertilities from multi-locus genetic data (typically microsatellites markers).

  • Mixed Effects Mating Model

Programs to analyse pollen dispersal from microsatelites data following the approach developed in Klein et al. 2008 are now available here.

  • Colon SGS PROJECT

A project named "ColonSGS: Set-up of a spatial genetic structure during a colonisation process: mathematical models and two case studies concerning wood species (cedar and beech)", granted by the ANR started in 2008. It will focus on the importance of long-distance dispersal event for spatial genetic structure.

  • DETAILS

 

  • Long distance dispersal

Fat-tailed dispersal kernels were known to behave qualitatively differently than thin-tailed dispersal kernels concerning the speed of advance of a colonization wave (Mollison 1977, Clark et al 2001). We proved that the exponential tails are also a critical point concerning the mixture of propagules from different sources : fat-tailed kernels lead to even propagule clouds when far from the sources, whereas propagule clouds become dominated by the closest source for thin-tailed kernels. The consequences of this property for the spatial pattern of genetic diversity during colonization will be fully investigated during the PhD of Julien.

Julien Fayard started his PhD in october 2006 supervised by François Lefèvre and myself, with a grant from the French Research Ministry. He works on Variability of the dispersal kernel along an expanding population. Impacts of the heterogeneity in the environment.

Characterizing the tail of dispersal kernels, particularly with respect to the property mentioned above, was also a main objective of numerous statistical studies in the sections below.

FAYARD J, KLEIN EK, LEFEVRE F, submitted. Long-range dispersal and the fate of a mutation arising in the colonization front. JEB.
OA.gif
KLEIN EK, LAVIGNE C, GOUYON PH, 2006 Mixing of propagules from discrete sources at long distance: comparing a dispersal tail to an exponential. BMC Ecology. 6:3

 

  • Mating systems in forest trees species

We extended the likelihood approaches for neutral markers previously used for estimation of selection gradients (Burczyk et al 2002) to estimate explicit dispersal kernels and investigate the shape of their tail. The approach was originally designed on Sorbus torminalis, and for this species the approach provided results quite consistent with those from the now classical TwoGener approach (Smouse et al 2004). With Pierre Gerard, we extended the method to account for genotyping errors typical of microsatellites (± 2bp) for a study on hybridization between two Fraxinus species. Finer characterizations of the composition of pollen clouds and how they depend on the spatial pattern of individuals around a mother tree are also of interest to me. This could lead to alternative spatial mating models no more based on a dispersal kernel. These topics will be central in the PhD of Florence and Gwendal.

On theis topic, I also collaborated with Catherine Bastien and her team in Orléans in the framework of INTERPOPGER. This was a project on Populus and Melampsora, granted by the national program Ecoger, that will finish at the end of 2008.

Gwendal Restoux defended his PhD in June 2009 on Spatio-temporal variability of mating system in Abies Alba. Bruno Fady (URFM) supervised with me this PhD granted by INRA EFPA and PACA region.

Florence Carpentier defended her PhD in june 2010 on Measuring pollen or seed dispersal from genetical markers partially observed. This PhD was supervised by Joël Chadœuf and me and granted by French Research Minister.

 
CARPENTIER F, CHADOEUF J, KLEIN EK, Considering selfing in the indirect methods estimating contemporary gene flow by pollen.

RESTOUX G, BONNET C, PICHOT C, VENDRAMIN B, KLEIN EK, FADY B, submitted, Variability of female reproductive success of the conifer tree Abies alba Mill: Pollen quantity vs pollen quality and implications for maintenance of mixed mating system.

OA.gif RESTOUX G, DASILVA DE, SAGNARD F, TORRE F, KLEIN EK, FADY B, 2008. Life at the margins: the mating system of Mediterranean conifers. Web Ecology 8: 94-102.
pdf.jpg ODDOU-MURATORIO S, KLEIN EK, 2008 Comparing direct versus indirect estimates of gene flow in a local population of a scattered tree species. Molecular Ecology 17: 2743-2754.
pdf.jpg KLEIN EK,  DESASSIS N, ODDOU-MURATORIO S, 2008, Pollen flow in the wildservice tree, Sorbus torminalis (L.) Crantz. Whole inter-individual variance of male fecundity estimated jointly with dispersal kernel. Molecular Ecology 17: 3323-3336.
ODDOU-MURATORIO S, KLEIN EK, AUSTERLITZ F, 2006. Real-time patterns of pollen flow in the wildservice tree, Sorbus torminalis III. Mating patterns and the ecological maternal neighborhood. Amercian Journal of Botany, 93: 1650-1659.

OA.gif GÉRARD P, KLEIN EK, AUSTERLITZ F, FERNANDEZ-MAJARRES JF, FRASCARIA-LACOSTE N, 2006. Assortative mating and differential male mating success in an ash hybrid zone population. BMC Evolutionary Biology, 6: 96.
pdf.jpg ODDOU-MURATORIO S, KLEIN EK, AUSTERLITZ F, 2005 Spatial pattern of real-time pollen flow inferred from parent-offspring analysis in a scattered tree species, S. torminalis. Molecular Ecology, 14: 4441-4452.
pdf.jpg
AUSTERLITZ F, DICK CW, DUTECH C, KLEIN EK, ODDOU-MURATORIO S, SMOUSE PE, SORK VL, 2004 Using genetic markers to estimate the pollen dispersal curve. Molecular Ecology 13: 937-954.

 

 

  • Pollen dispersal in crop species and GMO release — Oilseed rape

During my PhD, we estimated the dispersal kernel of oilseed rape from an experimental field with a GMHT patch in the middle. We proposed a method to analyse data from such experiments accounting for the spatial design used. Actually, it consisted in estimating a dispersal kernel using an inverse method such as that used for seed dispersal (Ribbens 1997, Tufto 1997, Clark 1998). This function was used in the model GeneSys (Colbach et al 2001) to forecast transgene escape in spatially explicit agronomical landscapes. During her PhD Celine estimated a dispersal kernel directly at landscape scale using microsatellites data and a statistical approach derived from those used on forest species. She found much fatter tailed kernels than those found at field scale.

My contirbution to this field is now limited to collaborations in the project GMBIOIMPACT. This project on oilseed rape is granted by the national program ANR OGM and managed by Jane Lecomte in Orsay. The team of Bernard Vaissière working at INRA Avignon on pollination by bees is also engaged in this project.

Céline Devaux defended her PhD on 19th of may 2006 entitled Modelling and estimating the long-distance and efficient dispersal of oilseed rape pollen, at the landscape level and within a field, supervised by Claire Lavigne and me, granted by INRA.


pdf.jpg DEVAUX C, KLEIN EK, LAVIGNE C, SAUSSE C, MESSEAN A, 2008 Environmental and landscape effects on cross-pollination rates observed at long-distance among French oilseed rape (Brassica napus) commercial fields. Journal of Applied Ecology 45: 803-812.
pdf.jpg DEVAUX C, LAVIGNE C, AUSTERLITZ F, KLEIN EK, 2007. Inferring oilseed rape pollination patterns from microsatellite markers data at the landscape scale. Molecular Ecology, 16:487-499.
pdf.jpg DEVAUX C, LAVIGNE C, FALENTIN GUYOMARC'H H, VAUTRIN S, LECOMTE J, KLEIN EK. 2005 High diversity of oilseed rape pollen clouds over an agro-ecosystem indicates long-distance dispersal. Molecular Ecology, 14: 2269-2280.
pdf.jpg KLEIN EK, LAVIGNE C, PICAULT H, RENARD M, GOUYON PH, 2006 Pollen dispersal of oilseed rape: estimation of the dispersal function and effecs of field dimension. Journal of Applied Ecology, 43: 141-151.
pdf.jpg
LAVIGNE C, KLEIN EK, VALLÉE P, PIERRE J, GODELLE B, RENARD M, 1998 A pollen-dispersal experiment with transgenic oilseed rape. Estimation of the average pollen dispersal of an individual plant within a field. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 96: 886-896.
  • Pollen dispersal in crop species and GMO release — Maize

Using an experimental field of yellow corn with a patch of blue corn in the middle we estimated dispersal kernels for corn. The statistical approach was similar to that used for oilseed rape but we used quasi-mechanistic models accounting for wind speed, main wind direction and difference of height between ears and panicles. The integration of this dispersal model with a model for flowering phenology was achieved within the MAPOD model that allows forecasting pollen flow within a spatially explicit corn landscape and an explicit meteorological scenario. This model is used to investigate coexistence rules for GM, non-GM and organic crops (Angevin)

pdf.jpg LAVIGNE C, KLEIN EK, MARI JF, LE BER F, ADAMCZYK K, MONOD H, ANGEVIN F, 2008 Relative impacts of closest fields and background pollen on GM impurity rates in non-GM harvests. Journal of Applied Ecology 45: 1104-1113.
pdf.jpg
ANGEVIN F, KLEIN EK, CHOIMET C, GAUFFRETEAU A, LAVIGNE C, MESSEAN A, MEYNARD JM, 2008. Modelling impacts of cropping systems and climate on maize cross pollination in agricultural landscapes: The MAPOD model. European Journal of Agronomy 28: 471-484.

KLEIN EK, LAVIGNE C, FOUEILLASSAR X, GOUYON PH, LARÉDO C, 2003 Corn pollen dispersal: quasi-mechanistic models and field experiments. Ecological Monographs 73: 131-150.

ANGEVIN F, KLEIN E, CHOIMET C, MEYNARD JM, DE ROUW A, SOHBI Y, 2001 Modélisation des effets des systèmes de culture et du climat sur les pollinisations croisées chez le maïs. Rapport du groupe 3 du programme de recherche "Pertinence économique et faisabilité d'une filière 'sans utilisation d'OGM' "., pp. 21-36. INRA - FNSEA.


  • Other publications
DARMENCY H, KLEIN EK, GESTAT DE GARAMBÉ T, GOUYON PH, RICHARD-MOLLARD MUCHEMBLED C,  Pollen dispersal in sugar beet production fields. Theoretical and Applied Genetics.

FALLOU-RUBIO D, GUIBAL F, KLEIN EK, BARITEAU M, LEFEVRE F, Variation and micro-evolution of individual phenotypic plasticity within a transplanted tree population. Journal of Evolutionary Biology.

LLAURENS V, BILLARD S, LEDUCQ JB, CASTRIC V, KLEIN EK, VEKEMANS X, 2008 Does frequency-dependent selection with complex dominance interactions accurately predict allelic frequencies at the self-incompatibility locus in Arabidopsis halleri? Evolution 62: 2545-2557.

KUNSTLER G, CHADOEUF J, KLEIN EK, CURT T, BOUCHARD M, LEPART J, 2007 Tree colonization of sub-Mediterranean grasslands: Effects of effective dispersal and shrub facilitation. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 37: 103-115.

LAVIGNE C, DEVAUX C, DEVILLE A, GARNIER A, KLEIN EK, LECOMTE J, PIVARD S, GOUYON PH, 2004 Potentials and limits of modelling to predict the impact of transgenic crops in wild species, Chapter 26 in Introgession from genetically modified plants into wild relatives and its consequences, edited by DEN NIJS HCM, BARTSCH D and SWEET J. CAB International, Oxon, UK.

LAVIGNE C, KLEIN EK, COUVET D, 2002 Using seed purity data to estimate an average pollen mediated gene flow from crops to wild relatives. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 104: 139-145.

KLEIN EK, LAREDO C, 1999 Optimal sampling designs for studies of gene flow: A comment on Assuncao and Jacobi. Evolution 53: 2002-2005.

BRACHET S, OLIVIERI I, GODELLE B, KLEIN EK, FRASCARIA-LACOSTE N, GOUYON PH, 1999 Dispersal and metapopulation viability in a heterogeneous landscape. Journal of Theoretical Biology 198: 479-495.

 

  • OTHER PAST AND PRESENT MAIN COLLABORATORS

Catherine Larédo from MIA Jouy-en-Josas supervised my PhD.
Claire Lavigne thought to extricate herself from the field of research on GM crops by transmitting me her PhD topic. She finally had to put up with the topic and me …
Frédéric Austerlitz supervised my M.Sc. thesis on coalescence and we collaborated on numerous projects during last years.
Sylvie Oddou-Muratorio converted me to microsatellites data and parentage analyses during her PhD on Sorbus torminalis.
Frédérique Angevin had the bravery to convert the maize dispersal model set up during my PhD into the MAPOD model…